Your Cool Home is supported by its readers. Please assume all links are affiliate links. If you purchase something from one of our links, we make a small commission from Amazon. Thank you!
Yes, you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro, but the swap will change the flavor profile of your dish in a noticeable way.
Italian parsley, also called flat-leaf parsley, has a fresh, slightly peppery taste that’s clean and mild.
Cilantro, on the other hand, brings a bright, citrusy punch that some people love and others absolutely hate.
So while you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro, you should know what you’re getting into before you start chopping.
In this post, we’ll cover when you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro, when you shouldn’t, and how to adjust your recipe so it still tastes great.
Let’s dig in.
Can You Substitute Italian Parsley for Cilantro?
You can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro, and it works best when you just need a fresh green garnish or a mild herbal note.
The two herbs look similar at a glance, which is why so many people confuse them at the store.
Both have green leaves, both get chopped into salsas and salads, and both add a pop of color to a finished plate.
But they are not the same herb, and they don’t taste the same either.
If you substitute Italian parsley for cilantro, expect a milder, grassier flavor rather than that signature citrus bite.
That’s not a bad thing, it just means the swap works better in some recipes than others.
1. They Look Almost Identical
Italian parsley and cilantro both have flat, vibrant green leaves that are easy to mix up.
People often ask if you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro simply because the two look so alike on the shelf.
The main visual giveaway is the leaf shape, since cilantro leaves tend to be a bit more rounded and lacy.
Italian parsley leaves are usually a little more pointed and deeply cut.
Still, when they’re chopped up, it’s almost impossible to tell them apart by sight alone.
2. Their Flavors Are Completely Different
The biggest reason to think twice before you substitute Italian parsley for cilantro is the flavor.
Cilantro has a bold, citrusy, almost soapy taste that comes from natural compounds called aldehydes.
Italian parsley is much milder, with a fresh, slightly peppery and grassy flavor.
If you substitute Italian parsley for cilantro in a recipe, the dish will taste softer and less vibrant.
It won’t be ruined, but it also won’t taste the way you expected.
When You Should Substitute Italian Parsley for Cilantro
There are plenty of times when you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro without anyone noticing much of a difference.
The key is to know which dishes rely on cilantro’s punch and which ones just need something green and fresh.
Here’s when the swap works well.
1. As a Garnish
If you’re just sprinkling herbs on top of a dish for color, you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro with zero worries.
A garnish is mostly about looks and a light fresh note, and Italian parsley delivers both.
Sprinkle it over tacos, soups, curries, or grilled meats and it’ll look just as pretty.
2. In Mild Sauces and Dressings
When a recipe calls for a small amount of cilantro in a creamy sauce or vinaigrette, Italian parsley is a safe stand-in.
You can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro in these cases because the herb isn’t the star of the show.
It’s playing a supporting role, and Italian parsley can handle that just fine.
3. When Someone at the Table Hates Cilantro
Some people genuinely can’t stand cilantro because of a genetic sensitivity to those aldehydes.
For them, it tastes like soap rather than citrus.
If that’s the case at your dinner table, you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro and everyone stays happy.
The dish loses a little brightness, but it gains a milder, crowd-pleasing flavor.
When You Shouldn’t Substitute Italian Parsley for Cilantro
Other times, you really shouldn’t substitute Italian parsley for cilantro if you want the recipe to taste right.
Here’s when to make the trip to the store instead.
1. In Authentic Salsas and Guacamole
Fresh salsa and guacamole live and die by their cilantro.
If you substitute Italian parsley for cilantro in guacamole, you’ll end up with something that tastes flat and a little sad.
Those dishes depend on that citrusy kick, and parsley simply can’t copy it.
2. In Cilantro-Heavy Dishes
Recipes like cilantro lime rice, chimichurri, or cilantro chutney put the herb front and center.
You can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro in these dishes, but the result will be a totally different meal.
It might still taste good, just not like what you set out to make.
3. When the Recipe Calls for Cilantro Specifically
If a recipe names cilantro, that’s usually a sign the flavor matters.
You can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro in a pinch, but taste as you go and adjust with lime juice or garlic.
Those additions can help replace some of the brightness you’re losing.
So, Can You Substitute Italian Parsley for Cilantro?
You can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro, and it works best as a garnish or in dishes where the herb plays a minor role.
Just remember that Italian parsley is milder and grassier, while cilantro brings a bold citrusy punch.
If you substitute Italian parsley for cilantro in salsa, guacamole, or cilantro-forward recipes, expect a different but still edible result.
So the next time you’re out of cilantro, you can substitute Italian parsley for cilantro with confidence, as long as you know what to expect.